80-year-old facing $23K bill after racing pigeons were seized while he was in hospital


Arthur Plasschaert has been racing pigeons as a passion since he was a 13-year-old in the Netherlands.

A retired actual property agent, he’s spent the final 5 a long time elevating and racing the birds about 140 kilometres east of Toronto, in Brighton, Ont.  Now, he says his pigeons have been taken away and he’s been left with nothing.

“I miss my birds,” Plasschaert mentioned.

“I’ve no spouse. I’ve no youngsters. That’s all I had, my birds.”

Until this previous winter, Plasschaert housed round 600 racing pigeons in lofts he constructed himself on a property he owns in Brighton. But the day earlier than Christmas 2021, he was hospitalized with COVID-19. Over the subsequent two months, he could be moved to the intensive care unit at Belleville General Hospital twice.

When he was lastly discharged final February, the Humane Society had confiscated his pigeons and he was left with a bill of $5,867 from the province. Since then, that bill has elevated to almost $23,000. 

Plasschaert depends on his Canada Pension for his earnings and mentioned he doesn’t have the cash to pay the bill. 

Plasschaert has been elevating racing pigeons as a passion since he was 13 years outdated. (Submitted by Arthur Plasschaert )

When he was hospitalized, Plasschaert didn’t have a plan in place to handle his pigeons. 

“I had no backup. I by no means thought I was going to be ending up like this,” he mentioned. 

From the hospital, he known as a few mates who work for the Township of Brighton. They mentioned they’d look after the birds for him however the township quickly known as them in to clear roads after a giant snowstorm. That meant they were unable to feed the birds for a number of days, he mentioned.

In the meantime, a involved neighbour who hadn’t seen Plasschaert in just a few days known as the Ontario Provincial Police to research his absence. When the OPP arrived at Plasschaert’s property, they discovered 337 of the pigeons lifeless. The Humane Society was known as in to take away the birds that survived, Plasschaert mentioned. 

Still in hospital, Plasschaert mentioned he obtained a cellphone name from the Humane Society telling him he would want to supply a brand new place to accommodate the birds inside 10 days. He would even be required to pay to accommodate and feed the birds for that interval.

Racing pigeons in one of the lofts Plasschaert built for them on his property
Plasschaert had 600 racing pigeons on his property earlier than being hospitalized for COVID-19. When he was discharged from the hospital, he had none. (Submitted by Arthur Plasschaert)

Plasschaert mentioned he indicated he could be unable to pay, and together with his medical situation on his thoughts, he instructed the Humane Society consultant that they might maintain the birds.

The consultant instructed him the birds would develop into property of the Crown after 10 days, Plasschaert mentioned. 

During this time he might barely rise up, he mentioned. He would usually be wanting breath simply making an attempt to stroll from his mattress to a chair in his hospital room, and that was earlier than being moved into intensive care.

At one level throughout his keep, a black envelope addressed to him on the hospital appeared in his room, however he was not in a position to learn the contents on the time. 

Months later, after spending time at a good friend’s home to proceed his restoration, Plasschaert found that the envelope contained the preliminary bill for $5,867.

It additionally contained a discover that he had a five-day window to enchantment the fees.

Plasschaert poses in front of a pigeon loft he built on his property. Pigeons can be seen roosting along the windows.
Plasschaert poses in entrance of one of many many pigeon lofts he constructed on the property he purchased in the Nineteen Seventies. (Submitted by Arthur Plasschaert)

He has since tried to schedule a tribunal listening to with the Animal Control Review Board (ACRB), the physique liable for resolving disputes and conducting hearings associated to animal welfare in Ontario. The board has indicated that as a result of he didn’t enchantment inside the five-day interval, it won’t open an enchantment file for him.

Plasschaert has obtained extra letters reflecting the rising price of housing and feeding his birds over the months. The newest quantity is $22,937.

The ACRB declined to touch upon Plasschaert’s case and didn’t reply to CBC Toronto’s questions on whether or not or not an exception might be made for somebody in a state of affairs like his.

Simon Dexter, a good friend and neighbour of Plasschaert’s, instructed CBC Toronto he would not perceive why an exception cannot be made. 

“It’s unhappy. He has been so dedicated to trying after these pigeons,” he mentioned. “He will get the COVID, he’s in the hospital, he is unable to do something and he will get sandbagged by it.”

Simon Dexter stands in front of some trees, plastic pigeons on a branch and a no trespassing sign.
Plasschaert’s good friend and neighbour, Simon Dexter, says it is unfair that the 80-year-old is facing such a big bill when he was in the intensive care unit combating for his life. (Paul Borkwood/CBC)

Dexter mentioned the truth that Plasschaert was bodily unable to open the preliminary envelope needs to be motive sufficient to drop the charges. 

“It could be very type, if the people who find themselves billing him appreciable cash daily, if they might look in the mirror and ask themselves ‘why?’ after they heard he was in the hospital,” he mentioned. 

But Jennifer Friedman, an animal welfare lawyer based mostly in Toronto, instructed CBC News it isn’t that easy. 

She believes Plasschaert might probably make a case that a unprecedented circumstance saved him from interesting the choice to take away his birds, however she mentioned it might be too late. 

“I’ve by no means seen a case that has been allowed after a number of months,” Friedman mentioned.

A building is surrounded by bushes, weeds and trees.
The pigeon lofts on Plasschaert’s property in Brighton, Ont. sit empty and overgrown with weeds and different vegetation. He says he has no motive to are inclined to the property now that his pigeons are gone. (Paul Borkwood/CBC)

She mentioned Plasschaert’s greatest guess could also be to ask the ACRB whether or not they’re keen to think about letting him simply pay for the preliminary 10 days that the birds were cared for. 

“In quite a lot of these conditions … the company will ask if the person needs to give up the animals,” she mentioned. “I’m undecided in this situation why that choice wasn’t provided to him.”

Friedman additionally identified that the quick five-day enchantment interval is purposely in place as a result of animals are totally different than inanimate types of property. 

“If you allow your bicycle or your sofa for weeks on finish, they’re going to nonetheless be there,” she mentioned. “But with residing beings, they have to be cared for every day.”

She additionally harassed the significance of getting an emergency plan in place to make sure animals are taken care of, whether or not it is 600 pigeons or one canine or cat. 

“There is a accountability whenever you take it upon your self to accumulate or undertake animals that you take care of them,” Friedman mentioned.

In spite of the emotional toll this case has taken on Plasschaert, he says he’s nonetheless hopeful he will get his pigeons again someday. 

“If I can get an enchantment from the animal assessment board, then I can set my case,” he mentioned.

“I hope that [they] shall be sympathetic sufficient to say, ‘yeah, you understand, have a look at the state of affairs the man was in.'”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here