A musical experiment from the ’80s to keep B.C. teens from loitering is now a global practice


In the mid-’80s, managers of 7-Eleven shops in B.C. confronted a drawback they thought was slicing into their backside line — youngsters hanging round the doorway. 

The firm felt teens lingering outdoors shops have been driving different clients away. Management in B.C. met with retailer employees and psychologists to brainstorm concepts to sort out the concern.

The resolution they got here up with appeared surprisingly easy: play classical or straightforward listening music generally known as Muzak in parking heaps to keep youngsters from hanging out. 

Music was used at 10 B.C. shops and shortly unfold to greater than 150 7-Eleven location throughout North America, in accordance to California-based musicologist Lily Hirsch. In the years that adopted, the practice of utilizing music as a deterrent has been used throughout the world.

WATCH | The background music that helps B.C. comfort shops keep loiterers away

The background music that helps B.C. comfort shops keep loiterers away

On Sept. 3, 1990, CBC’s Ian Hanomansing visited a 7-Eleven in Richmond, B.C., that was utilizing a new software to cease younger folks from loitering in entrance of their retailer: Muzak.

Hirsch’s guide, Music in American Crime Prevention and Punishment, contains a assertion from the firm saying it began the practice at a number of of its B.C.-based shops in 1985. 

Hirsch writes that there are earlier examples of companies utilizing music to keep folks from lingering, however 7-Eleven says it is “the first firm purposely to flip programmed music’s main perform from lure to repellent” and it “seems to be the first company to have sanctioned such an method as coverage.”

“I feel different folks did it subconsciously round the identical time, however 7-Eleven took possession of it,” Hirsch instructed CBC News.

That method, which 7-Eleven developed in B.C., continues to pop up round the world. Hirsch says she often comes throughout media studies discussing variations on the identical theme. 

In 2012, the Washington Post wrote about classical music being performed at the New York Port Authority. In 2019, a city in Florida garnered consideration for blasting the youngsters’s track Baby Shark to keep homeless folks from congregating outdoors an occasions centre. 

Last yr, opera music was blasted outdoors a drop-in area and protected consumption web site in Prince George, a practice that native outreach employees referred to as “atrocious.” 

WATCH | Repetitive opera music blaring at Prince George drop-in centre:

Opera music performed to drive away folks close to drop-in centre

Some outreach employees and volunteers are upset after the Fire Pit, a cultural drop-in centre in downtown Prince George, began taking part in opera music making an attempt to drive away folks sitting outdoors the constructing, which additionally homes a protected consumption web site.

7-Eleven has not responded to a request for remark about whether or not it nonetheless performs music outdoors any of its shops. 

Victoria 7-Eleven criticized to be used of dripping water

The comfort retailer chain just lately confronted criticism after certainly one of its shops in Victoria set up a system that intentionally dripped water from the underside of an awning to deter folks from loitering.

Advocates for weak populations in the metropolis have mentioned the use of dripping water to forestall loitering was degrading, particularly for homeless folks. 

A current report in the Times-Colonist says the retailer, positioned on Quadra and Yates streets, has stopped utilizing the tactic. CBC News has requested 7-Eleven for remark, however has but to obtain a response. 

Marking area with music

While the dripping water deterrent did not final lengthy, the firm’s musical ways seem to have endurance. 

Hirsch mentioned she first turned all in favour of the matter after studying a 2006 information story about a suburb of Sydney, Australia utilizing Barry Manilow music to repel youngsters.

Hirsch notes that most individuals have constructive associations with music, which makes it a extra delicate software to forestall loitering. Dripping water feels extra intrusive than piping Mandy by way of loudspeakers, she says.

“It was marking area, speaking this area does not belong to you, however they might use these constructive associations with music to create this type of confusion and this believable deniability,” she mentioned.

A 7-Eleven retailer in downtown Victoria confronted criticism after organising a water drip system to deter folks from loitering. (Kathryn Marlow/CBC News)

In Sept. 1990, CBC News visited a 7-Eleven retailer in Richmond, B.C., that performed Muzak outdoors the retailer. Manager Kevin St. Denis mentioned it was a hit with at the least one neighbouring family. 

“They hear it by way of their bed room and so they say it helps them go to sleep,” he mentioned.

While the music performed outdoors shops could also be smooth and lilting, Hirsch says the message it sends is loud and clear. 

“Really what’s occurring is you are segregating area.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here