Can comedy be a climate solution?


Our planet is altering. So is our journalism. This weekly publication is a part of a CBC Information initiative entitled “Our Altering Planet” to point out and clarify the results of local weather change. Sustain with the most recent information on our Local weather and Surroundings web page.

Join right here to get this text in your inbox each Thursday.

This week:

  • Can comedy be a local weather resolution?
  • The EU’s telephone charger choice is a strike towards e-waste
  • Salmon wrestle to spawn amid record-setting B.C. drought

Can comedy be a local weather resolution?

(Chelsea Hackett (2019))

Given the onslaught of utmost climate occasions within the final yr, many would say that local weather change is not any laughing matter. However two teachers say in any other case.

Beth Osnes is an affiliate professor of theatre and efficiency research on the College of Colorado, and in her analysis, she has seen that humour influences decision-making and societal change. 

So she teamed up with Max Boykoff, an affiliate professor in environmental research at U of C, to concoct a social experiment that meshed local weather communication and comedy.

“What we search to do by means of our analysis is to grasp below what circumstances [we can] improve the methods during which individuals are discovering pathways to speak about local weather change and from there, inspiring better engagement in motion,” mentioned Boykoff.

It is a crucial inquiry at a time when comparatively few individuals appear to be speaking about local weather. Based on a research executed by Yale College and George Mason College, lower than 40 per cent of individuals within the U.S. are discussing international warming with others “typically” and even “sometimes.” 

Osnes and Boykoff hypothesized that local weather comedy might be one repair. 

They put their idea to the check of their inventive local weather communication course and the Worldwide Comedy & Local weather Change Brief Video Competitors. They tasked college students with creating comedy sketches round local weather points and options (as within the photograph above). One video from 2021 is a satirical Christmas industrial from fossil gasoline large Exxon that notes “this vacation season … we’re spreading large disinformation — discuss gaslighting!”

“[The students] don’t make gentle of the difficulty of local weather change, however they’re bringing gentle to this challenge and I believe that is the factor that they carry by means of this expertise,” mentioned Osnes. She confused that comedy helps us “discover what unites us above what divides us.” 

She and Boykoff say it begins with assembly individuals the place they’re. New York-based standup comic Chuck Good is aware of this properly.

“Local weather is a matter that impacts everybody indirectly,” he mentioned. “The very first thing I say is, do not speak to individuals in New York about polar bears as a result of they do not care … however they could be enthusiastic about environmental justice, they could be enthusiastic about power prices [and] they could be enthusiastic about jobs.”

His jokes vary from poking enjoyable at self-righteous eco-warriors to ragging on the more and more chaotic fluctuations within the climate to teasing the general public and media on their gradual response to local weather change. No particular person or matter is off-limits. 

Good has been marrying science and comedy for years on the podcast StarTalk Radio, with famous astrophysicist and writer Neil deGrasse Tyson. In his spare time, Good works remotely on an ongoing foundation with Osnes and Boykoff’s college students to workshop their comedy sketches for his or her end-of-year occasion, Stand Up for Local weather Change. 

He says comedy relieves the awkwardness and pressure of adverse conversations and will get individuals speaking.

“There have been a number of research executed the place while you encounter feelings if you are studying, you keep what you might be studying significantly better,” Good advised What On Earth host Laura Lynch. “So if I elicit the happiness [or] chemical response that comes together with laughter [and] if I induce that whereas I am providing you with data, you are extra more likely to settle for the data.”

Osnes, Boykoff and Good proved that in their final local weather comedy standup occasion in April 2022, which occurred in varied U.S. cities. Roughly two-thirds of the viewers didn’t know they have been attending a climate-themed comedy present, however it did not cease quite a few individuals from approaching the organizers afterwards to debate local weather motion sources. The jokes clearly bought viewers members considering. 

“I’d say to everybody, irrespective of who you might be, that there’s a manner and a spot for you on this resolution,” Good mentioned.

— Dannielle Piper

Reader suggestions

Murray Chantler:

“I simply completed studying in regards to the Australian hairdresser who proactively addresses the difficulty of local weather change together with her purchasers, and has subsequently branched out into main workshops to show others in her occupation easy methods to provoke the identical outreach with their purchasers. Studying this text actually made my day, introduced a smile to my face and uplifted my spirit; how refreshing and inspirational it’s to know that there are individuals like Ms. Garcia on the market who’re taking the initiative to make a distinction within the struggle towards local weather change. Kudos to Ms. Garcia!”

Previous problems with What on Earth? are proper right here.

CBC Information just lately launched a devoted local weather web page, which will be discovered right here.

Additionally, take a look at our radio present and podcast. This week, we speak to younger Black Canadians about how they’re breaking obstacles within the local weather motion and we hear from the “father of environmental justice” about the place the wrestle started. What On Earth now airs on Sundays at 11 a.m. ET, 11:30 a.m. in Newfoundland and Labrador. Subscribe in your favorite podcast app or hear it on demand at CBC Hear.

The Large Image: One small step towards much less e-waste

Earlier this week, MPs within the European Parliament voted to resolve a problem that has bedevilled tech customers: incompatible charging cables. The result’s that the USB-C charging port will probably be the usual for all small- and medium-sized digital gadgets offered within the EU by 2024.

It is considered the primary laws on the planet meant to standardize charging ports for objects like telephones and laptops. Not solely will it take away a serious irritant for a lot of shoppers, however it’s being touted as a win for the atmosphere, in that it’s going to produce much less digital waste. 

Most producers use a model of the USB normal (which stands for Common Serial Bus), however Apple famously doesn’t. It employs its proprietary Lightning port (seen on the left within the photograph beneath) throughout most of its merchandise. Apple has lengthy lobbied towards charger standardization, arguing it stifles innovation and that it could the truth is create extra e-waste. 

Alex Agius Saliba, who led the negotiations for the 27-member EU on this challenge, acknowledged that outright banning outdated chargers would have an antagonistic affect on shoppers and the atmosphere, which is why the bloc is urging producers to progressively part out older merchandise.

Three different smartphone chargers.
(Craig Chivers/CBC)

Sizzling and bothered: Provocative concepts from across the net

Salmon wrestle to spawn amid record-setting B.C. drought

(Sarah Mund)

A lot of B.C. is experiencing drought and ongoing sizzling climate has left streams working dry, leaving no manner for some salmon to return to their spawning grounds, killing lots of in a mass die-off on the province’s central coast.

The state of affairs has scientists and salmon watchers involved.

The Pacific Salmon Fee initially projected a return of 9.8 million fish this yr. By August, predictions have been diminished to five.5 million. This was readjusted once more, on Sept. 28, to six.8 million.

There have been record-low rainfalls in September, and dry climate and warmth have continued into October, a month identified for rain. For some migrating salmon, that lack of moisture is proving lethal.

The variety of salmon returning to the Neekas River, about 25 kilometres north of Bella Bella, has been declining for many years, from a mean of 47,000 within the Nineteen Seventies to only 750 in 2021, based on federal knowledge from Fisheries and Oceans Canada.

This previous weekend, researchers found piles of lifeless fish — principally pink salmon — floating useless or plastered collectively alongside the underside of the Neekas close to Spiller Channel.

Pictures and movies taken by German anthropologist Sarah Mund, who was serving to Simon Fraser College salmon counters, present what look like lots of of salmon. Many have been mendacity limp over logs or alongside a creek mattress, or floating in shallow, heat waters of a creek that is normally a lot deeper this time of yr.

“To see it … come to this magnitude is sort of surprising,” mentioned William Housty, the conservation supervisor for the Heiltsuk First Nation in Bella Bella.

He estimates that if this scene is extrapolated over many creeks, it is probably lots of of hundreds of fish have died alongside rivers and streams of their territory this yr due to the nice and cozy temperatures and low water ranges.

Housty mentioned that the total affect of a mass die-off of fish will not be seen till about 2026, when the grownup salmon spawned this yr return.

Each fall, salmon return to the rivers the place they hatched from eggs and struggle upstream to spawning grounds. Females dig a nest and their eggs are fertilized by males who cloud the water with their milt (seminal fluid). Most grownup salmon then die, leaving their future to the fry which might be in a position to develop and survive predators. 

Whereas it isn’t remarkable for salmon to endure or die due to low rainfall, this mass die-off is “irregular,” mentioned Kyle Wilson, an utilized quantitative biologist with Central Coast Indigenous Useful resource Alliance. 

He blamed it, partially, on the recent, dry climate, adopted by a little bit of current rain that he says “tricked” salmon to move upstream, to their deaths.

He predicts only a few pink will survive on this creek — and solely in deeper swimming pools greater up the waterway. Nevertheless it is probably not a complete disaster, he says, as pink salmon from different river programs might decide to spawn within the Neekas River.

Till then, Wilson says the fish loss will have an effect on predators like bears, wolves and eagles. It should additionally have an effect on the industrial and Indigenous fisheries that depend on the salmon that return to central B.C. streams every fall.

The identical situation is taking part in out in different components of the province. Tens of hundreds of finger-length salmon fry are launched every year from streams into the Burrard Inlet. Dave Bennie, who has volunteered on the Midday’s Creek salmon hatchery for the Port Moody Ecological Society for 28 years, additionally calls it “irregular.”

“I do not know what to say to youngsters. It is dry, there is no water. There isn’t any fish,” mentioned Bennie. “[I’ve] by no means seen it this low.”

He factors out that salmon are leaping offshore, however the creek mattress is so dry that the chum and coho returning cannot get from the ocean into Midday’s Creek to swim upstream to spawn.

“Yearly, much less and fewer come again,” mentioned Bennie, whereas sitting on dry rocks in a creek that he says would normally be flowing as excessive as his chest by October.

For now, surviving fry conceal within the tiny swimming pools beneath the rocks, however he says that leaves them weak to predators like otters and blue herons, to not point out the unseasonable warmth. He fears for all of the Burrard Inlet hatcheries.

“We might lose the whole lot — all of the work we have executed for years and years.”

– Yvette Brend

Keep in contact!

Are there points you want us to cowl? Questions you need answered? Do you simply wish to share a form phrase? We might love to listen to from you. E mail us at

Join right here to get What on Earth? in your inbox each Thursday.

Editor: Andre Mayer | Brand design: Sködt McNalty


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here