Canadian politics: Poilievre and Trudeau spar at QP


There’s been a 20-year collection of middleweight clashes within the parliamentary combat membership – Chretien vs. Day, Martin vs. Harper, Harper vs. Mulcair, Trudeau vs. O’Toole – however nothing comes near the slugfest now raging between Conservative chief Pierre Poilievre and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

After three grudge-settling matches this fall, which is all of the prime minister has managed to point out up for within the dozen days because the Home returned to regular Query Interval operations, my scorecard is Pierre Poilievre 2, Justin Trudeau 1.

For his or her first two encounters, the fledging Official Opposition chief clearly had the higher hand.

However give Thursday to the prime minister for his neck-wrenching subject change. Answering a query in regards to the rising price of Thanksgiving dinners, Trudeau segued to the story a few boneheaded Poilievre staffer who had linked their boss’s YouTube messaging to a misogynistic on-line motion.

Poilievre knew it seemed dangerous, significantly given his fame of taking part in footsie with extremist components. He stood silently to endure 20 seconds of high-volume Liberal shaming after Trudeau demanded an apology.

However he didn’t apologize, merely condemning the motion earlier than swinging wildly into the previous to assault Trudeau’s sins, be it carrying blackface or firing Jody Wilson-Raybould as lawyer basic.

It didn’t fairly join as an emergency defensive technique, however generally it is best to flail away and transfer on as shortly as doable.

The fact of Query Interval in Canada is that it hasn’t produced a political bombshell since March 2003 when then-prime minister Jean Chretien revealed Canada wouldn’t go to struggle in Iraq and not using a United Nations Safety Council decision.

That implies a thousand-question hole full of huffing and puffing because the Home was final blown away by any main revelation from a chief minister.

However breaking information isn’t its main goal. On this age of social media, Query Interval has turn into a mine for YouTube quips, a sentence or two for the nightly newscasts or a pair quotes for print media.

But there’s one thing about these two leaders, not less than going by their first trio of matches, which makes the stakes appear larger.

Poilievre doesn’t recite questions from a chunk of paper. He hurls them into the prime minister’s face, rubs within the political salt and ranges a sneering sidebar or two, often involving Trudeau’s use of presidency jets which, to be honest, is the one manner he’s allowed to fly.

Trudeau for his half has upped his standard going-through-the-motions efficiency, which was noticeable on Wednesday when he stickhandled each query pretty nicely with out studying his cheat sheets or sliding right into a stammer.

Now for my media pals rolling their eyes at this try to construct drama out of dogma, allow us to concede that the duelling themes between these two leaders are pretty repetitious.

Poilievre sounds the alarm a few future the place the tripling of carbon taxation costs pumpkin pie out of the Thanksgiving meals finances.

Trudeau retorts how the hurricane, flooding and wildfire local weather catastrophes he has seen are grounds for a hefty pricing of air pollution.

Poilievre snarks that boosting the carbon value is a tax plan, not a local weather change plan, which has but to fulfill decrease emission targets.

Trudeau insists common Canadians get all of the carbon tax they pay again and extra.

And so it goes, blah, blah and extra blah, however there’s a noticeable uptake in depth between these two leaders.

(Sadly, there’s no corresponding enchancment from Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland, who continues to excel at irritating, arm-waving, talk-down double-speak – pleading with the Conservatives to assist her authorities’s social packages in a single sentence and ridiculing them for doing so within the subsequent. The extra you watch her, the more durable it’s to see her as future prime ministerial materials.)

Trudeau appears to be rising to tackle Poilievre as if he’s in a boxing match with a pugilistic senator or one thing.

This fight area is not only political, it’s private. It’s Pierre’s whine verses Justin’s woke; spontaneity verses scripting; the rising price of potatoes verses the disaster of Fiona; dangerous hair verses good.

It would by no means win a rankings battle towards any afternoon cleaning soap opera, however this fall’s editions of Query Interval, after a future as a theatrical bomb begging for the curtain to come back down, is now a semi-entertaining conflict of management kinds, beliefs, personalities and coverage.

That’s the underside line.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here