Corman Park police dispute woman’s claims about being forced to walk to Saskatoon after car seized


A Big River, Sask., girl and her grownup son ended up mountain climbing alongside Highway 12 in the dead of night with a walker and suitcases for shut to an hour on the evening of Nov. 15 after a Corman Park Police Service constable impounded their car.

On this a lot Sylvia Joseph, her son Roddy Joseph and Corman Park Police Service Chief Ronald Chomyn agree.

They disagree, nonetheless, on how the 54-year-old and her 38-year-old son got here to be pushing her belongings on the shoulder of the busy freeway on that winter evening. 

Sylvia says the Corman park officer left them no alternative after impounding the car. The car was seized as a result of Roddy, who was driving, had examined constructive for pot when given an oral swab by the officer.

“So he says, ‘You’re gonna have to pack up all of your stuff and discover a experience or begin strolling,’ ” Sylvia mentioned.

The officer didn’t provide the choice of switching drivers in order that they might proceed on their manner.

Chief Chomyn mentioned audio and video of the interactions had been captured on a physique digicam. Chomyn mentioned he has reviewed the footage, however is unable to share it with CBC.

Chomyn mentioned that at no level did the officer recommend strolling to the town as an choice.

“Our officer talked to the driving force, her son, and expressed that ‘I do not assume it is secure, it is harmful, you guys want to prepare for a experience or let me name you a cab,’ ” he mentioned.

“She selected not to. And , legally we won’t cease somebody from strolling on the freeway.”

Corman Park Police Service Chief Ronald Chomyn stands by his officer. (CBC)

Erratic driving

Corman Park is a rural municipality that surrounds Saskatoon.

Police say the communication started when the Corman Park constable started following a gray Lincoln Town Car that was travelling south on Highway 12 round 8 p.m. CST on Nov. 15. It was darkish, windy and about –5 C.

The car caught the officer’s consideration as a result of it was not staying in its lane, Chomyn mentioned.

Sylvia is a member of the Big River First Nation, about 220 kilometres north of Saskatoon. Once every week, she travels from her dwelling at Debden, close to the First Nation, to Saskatoon for dialysis at St. Paul’s Hospital.

She mentioned that, on Nov. 15, she had began off behind the wheel, along with her 38-year-old son Roddy within the passenger seat, however they switched off at Blaine Lake when Sylvia obtained drained. She and Roddy each confirmed that he had smoked pot earlier within the day.

Roddy mentioned he struggled retaining the mid-90s Lincoln straight in its lane as a result of it had issues with the steering and low strain in a entrance tire.

Roddy mentioned he woke his Mom once they had been pulled over. It occurred simply south of Martensville, the place Highway 12 intersects with Township Road 382. The officer checked Roddy’s licence, then took Roddy to his cruiser to do an oral swab for pot.

The swab examined constructive which, by regulation, meant that the Joseph’s car can be routinely impounded for 3 days. This ticket was really for 30 days as a result of, though Sylvia had a sound license, Roddy was not approved to drive, police say.

Roadside suspension

Sylvia mentioned the constable advised them they might both name a taxi, get somebody to choose them up — or walk. She mentioned she had no cash for a taxi.

“We haven’t got cash. When I come over right here, the band solely offers me sufficient cash for gasoline. I purchase one thing to drink and one thing to snack on the way in which trigger it is a two-and-a-half hour drive,” she mentioned.

She mentioned she requested whether or not the officer would pay for the taxi and he mentioned no.

Roddy then started calling Sylvia’s sister in Saskatoon, however she was caring for one other member of the family and was not selecting up.

Sylvia Joseph in her Lincoln Town Car. (Evelyn Halkett/Submitted)

Evelyn Halkett, Sylvia’s sister, mentioned she lastly turned on her cellphone after 9 p.m. CST, and found a sequence of texts and missed cellphone messages from her nephew and sister.

Halkett supplied copies of the time-stamped messages to CBC.

“Hello my Sissy. I would like you to come choose me up. We obtained my car taken for 30 days,” reads the primary message, a textual content at 8:16 p.m. CST.

Then follows a sequence of missed calls — at 8:17, 8:19, 8:22, 8:24, 8:28, 8:29 — till Evelyn lastly picks up after 9 p.m. CST.

She raced north out of the town to choose up her sister and nephew.

“So I’m coming down Idylwyld [Drive], passing Costco and so I’m trying on my left-hand facet pondering, OK, the place are they? My coronary heart is hurting as a result of it is my sister, strolling along with her walker, her car obtained taken away,” she mentioned.

“I used to be virtually to the purpose of rushing as a result of it is chilly on the market. And she may barely walk, all her stuff had been piled on the walker. So she’s pushing that.”

Sylvia mentioned she’s talking out now as a result of she would not need anybody else to undergo the same expertise.

“I need these cops to take it straightforward on Natives, all Natives. Treat them truthful like all people else. Don’t deal with them tough like what they did to me.”

Chomyn mentioned race had nothing to do with what occurred.

“It’s not a race concern. It would not matter. We take care of First Nations folks on a regular basis,” he mentioned.

Police perspective

Chomyn mentioned the communication with the constable, from the preliminary cease to the demand for an oral swab to the tow truck arriving, lasted about an hour.

He mentioned the physique digicam footage confirmed the conversations between Sylvia, Roddy and the officer had been civil and non-confrontational. Roddy, for instance, didn’t complain or dispute the constructive pot studying, Chomyn mentioned.

There are two phases to pot testing on the roadside.

The oral swab take a look at that Roddy took would not decide precisely how a lot THC is in somebody’s physique, or if somebody is definitely impaired by the pot of their system. It merely offers a move or fail end result if somebody has greater than 25 nanograms of THC of their system.

Chomyn mentioned that Roddy didn’t present indicators of impairment, so he was not given additional testing at a police station.

However, Chomyn mentioned that after the officer decided Roddy had been driving with out a legitimate licence, he had no discretion on whether or not impound the automobile.

Chomyn mentioned the officer spoke with Sylvia after the car was impounded.

“He requested her what what the plan was as a result of the automobile was being seized. He requested if she would love him to name her a cab, and he or she requested if he would pay for it … and he mentioned no, we do not pay for cabs,” he mentioned.

“He requested if she was in a position to pay money for anybody to choose them up and he or she mentioned no. And he mentioned, ‘So what’s your plan?’ And she mentioned, ‘I’ll walk.’ And she turned and walked away and went again to the car and began getting her stuff out.”

Chomyn mentioned the officer, who has somewhat greater than two years expertise, couldn’t drive them to keep,

“Roddy had been served all his documentation. It wasn’t a prison arrest, he wasn’t below arrest. They weren’t being detained after that reality for any purpose.”

Chomyn mentioned that, given the quantity of baggage concerned and that it was two folks, the officer didn’t have house within the cruiser to drive them into the town.

Later, after the tow truck had retrieved the car, the officer drove south test on their progress, Chomyn mentioned.

“He did drive south towards the town on the lookout for them and was unable to to see them, so he assumed that they’d safely made it in, that any person had stopped or they’d referred to as the cab,” he mentioned.

Roddy Joseph says he is nonetheless shaken. (CBC)

Roddy mentioned he is nonetheless shaken by what occurred.

“I simply felt ugly that I had to walk with my mom. It’s unreal,” he mentioned.

“It’s not supposed to be like that.”

Chomyn declined to speculate whether or not the officer may — or ought to — have contacted RCMP to alert them about the pair strolling down the freeway, or whether or not the officer would have reacted in another way had it been considerably colder that evening.

“They had been strolling from the place they had been on a minus-five evening,” he mentioned.

“The hazard was from visitors, or one thing like. It wasn’t from the weather.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here