Danielle Smith: didn’t mean to trivialize with unvaccinated comment


Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she didn’t mean to trivialize prejudice confronted by minority communities when she recommended unvaccinated individuals have skilled probably the most discrimination she has ever seen in her lifetime.

Smith’s comment on her first day as premier drew criticism from throughout Canada — together with British Columbia Premier John Horgan, who referred to as it “laughable,” and at the least one Jewish group who says it reached out to her workplace to categorical concern.

Smith mentioned in an announcement Wednesday that she meant to underline the mistreatment of people who selected not to be vaccinated.

“I need to be clear that I didn’t intend to trivialize in any means the discrimination confronted by minority communities and different persecuted teams or create any false equivalencies to the horrible historic discrimination and persecution suffered by so many minority teams,” mentioned the assertion.

Smith was sworn in Tuesday as Alberta’s new premier after the United Conservative Party elected her in a management race to exchange Jason Kenney as chief and premier.

Later within the day, at her first information convention as premier, Smith mentioned she would shake up the highest tier of the well being system inside three months and amend provincial human rights regulation to defend those that select not to get vaccinated for ailments together with COVID-19.

“(The unvaccinated) have been probably the most discriminated-against group that I’ve ever witnessed in my lifetime,” mentioned the 51-year-old.

“I do not assume I’ve ever skilled a state of affairs in my lifetime the place an individual was fired from their job or not allowed to watch their children play hockey or not allowed to go go to a beloved one in long-term care or hospital, not allowed to get on a airplane to both go throughout the nation to see household and even journey throughout the border.”

Horgan, who’s to step down as B.C.’s NDP premier later this yr, responded to Smith’s comment Wednesday in an interview with C-FAX Radio in Victoria.

“It’s laughable, fairly frankly,” Horgan when requested about Smith’s comment by radio host Al Ferraby.

Horgan mentioned the worldwide neighborhood has simply gone via an unprecedented time with the COVID-19 pandemic — “nothing like this in over 100 years going again to the Spanish influenza.”

“On high of that, now we have a toxic drug provide that’s killing our buddies and our neighbours. At the identical time, we’re working out of individuals to present the companies,” Horgan mentioned.

“For the incoming premier to deal with a sliver of the inhabitants who selected not to get vaccinated when there are all these different challenges appears short-sighted to me. And I simply disagree with her. I consider the overwhelming majority of Canadians understood we had a collective accountability.”

Alberta Health knowledge exhibits greater than 82 per cent of the province’s complete inhabitants has obtained a primary dose of COVID-19 vaccine and practically 78 per cent of the inhabitants has two doses.

Jewish Edmonton mentioned on social media that it’s eager to meet with Smith to talk about antisemitism and discrimination in the neighborhood.

Duane Bratt, a political scientist at Mount Royal University in Calgary, mentioned Smith’s comment could be laughable if she weren’t the premier.

“This exhibits what drove her marketing campaign and who her supporters are,” he mentioned.

Bratt mentioned Smith’s comment is offensive as a result of there was lots of discrimination previously 50-plus years.

“We nonetheless had compelled sterilization. We had residential faculties up till the Nineties,” he mentioned. “We didn’t have homosexual marriage till (2005).”

Bratt mentioned race, faith, sexual orientation and disabilities aren’t selections.

“Those are issues that you’ve got and that is why we do not enable discrimination based mostly on that,” he mentioned. “Deciding not to be vaccinated is a selection that folks make.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first printed Oct. 12, 2022.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here