Danielle Smith wants vaccine status to be a human right. Expect a petri dish of problems


There’s been a lot mentioned, and justifiably so, about new Premier Danielle Smith’s remarks that the unvaccinated have been extra discriminated in opposition to than some other group within the final half-century — a 50-year spell that is been marked by systemic racism in opposition to varied teams, the rise of Islamophobia and transphobia, ongoing homophobia and anti-Semitism, continued mistreatment of Indigenous folks, and on and on

She tried to clear up her remarks, however which may not imply these unsettled by what she mentioned will overlook or forgive.

Far much less consideration has been paid, nevertheless, to unpacking the explanation she was prompted to share her ideas on the extent of discrimination in opposition to individuals who’ve chosen not to get COVID-19 inoculations. 

One of Smith’s key management marketing campaign guarantees, which she’s apparently decided to carry by means of, is to enshrine protections within the Alberta Human Rights Act for folks primarily based on vaccination status.

Doing so would put whether or not or not one selected a COVID jab on par with gender, sexual orientation, race, nation of origin and spiritual beliefs within the province’s landmark anti-discrimination legislation. But past the inherent controversy of equating vaccination with these different points, there are different real-life penalties at play if the Alberta legislature makes this modification.

The human proper that might do incorrect to others

Smith’s proposed transfer might have vital ramifications for the state of Alberta well being care, nicely past this pandemic.

Because as onerous as it might be for some of us, greater than two years on, let’s put aside COVID for a second, even whether it is what motivated Smith to marketing campaign on this transfer.

Vaccine mandates and guidelines aren’t one thing that immediately burst into the world in 2021, when Pfizer, Moderna and different firms devised pictures to shield in opposition to the coronavirus. Such necessities have lengthy been frequent for health-care staff, well being sciences college students and others in that realm. Requirements have remained in place for different vaccinations — Hepatitis B, measles, tetanus and different easily-preventable illnesses with well-established immunization applications.

Here, for instance, is the University of Alberta well being school’s kind. And a job discover to be a registered nurse at Covenant Health’s hospital in Camrose, citing the requirement that profitable candidates have the annual influenza vaccine.

And outdoors of well being care, Lakeland College in Vermilion has required that college students of their hairstyling and esthetician applications present proof of vaccination for Hep B and measles, mumps and rubella.

Anti-vaccine protesters outdoors the Royal Alexandra Hospital in Edmonton in September 2021. (Scott Neufeld/CBC)

In the Alberta that Smith promised United Conservatives, it would not even be acceptable for bosses to ask for vaccination data. In an Aug. 31 information launch, her marketing campaign promised a coverage “prohibiting employers from requiring the vaccination and different well being data of Albertans.”

With such pledges, Smith appealed to the minority phase of Albertans who both weren’t vaccinated for COVID — that is solely 9 per cent of these older than 12 — or had been aggrieved that they had been pushed to accomplish that, lest they face penalties at their office, or be restricted of their means to fly, dine in eating places or go to long-term care properties.

But when you’re establishing a human proper to refuse vaccines and never face employment or client penalties, Smith presumably can not design a protected class solely pertaining to immunization from one illness. One assumes it might have to apply to all vaccinations.

The Alberta Human Rights Act would successfully be defending a newly-created freedom of one group of residents, and in so doing limiting protections in opposition to illness for the opposite Albertans of their midst. That is, health-care staff would be free to be unprotected in opposition to an array of different illnesses as they work in hospitals.

“You’re opening the door to having resurgences of vaccine-preventable illnesses probably unfold in a well being care setting,” mentioned Dr. Lynora Saxinger, an infectious illnesses specialist on the University of Alberta.

Hep B, for instance, is a continual liver an infection that may lead to most cancers or liver failure, and is transmitted simply by means of blood. That vaccine, Saxinger mentioned, has largely eliminated the earlier dangers of Hep B outbreaks in hospitals or different well being amenities.

A registered nurse was the primary health-care employee in Grande Prairie, Alta., to obtain the COVID-19 vaccine in December 2020. By the time COVID vaccines grew to become obligatory the next autumn, greater than 97 per cent of Alberta Health Services staff had been immunized. (Chris Beauchamp/Alberta Health Services)

As with the COVID vaccine guidelines, the health-care sector’s insurance policies for different vaccination guidelines or disclosures had been nicely developed and thought of, with dialogue of impacts to liberties and staff’ private selection weighed in opposition to the implications of larger dangers to hospital sufferers. Smith’s plan would yank that call out of the palms of well being directors and have it fall squarely on the “freedom” aspect of that equation.

“It’s mainly saying that the science and the ethics behind what we’re doing proper now do not matter anymore, and that you would be able to have somebody in well being care who might probably be carrying a transmissible infectious illness and exposing sufferers to it on an ongoing foundation and never do something about it,” Saxinger mentioned.

New-wave considering 

It’s clear Smith has the health-care sector in her sights for this tough crackdown on means to stop unvaccinated staff. She has repeatedly linked the system’s pressure to the truth that well being employers had required COVID vaccinations.

But the overwhelming majority of AHS staff complied with the requirement — over 97.7 per cent of part- and full-time employees, and 99.8 per cent of medical doctors. And when AHS was ordered by the Kenney authorities to rescind its mandate for workers in March, the company anticipated to add again a mere 750 staff. More than 121,000 are on employees at AHS and its subsidiaries.

And keep in mind, these vaccine guidelines got here into impact through the Delta wave, earlier than Omicron modified the stakes with regards to safety in opposition to transmission. Employers from the federal authorities to Alberta Health Services have dropped their COVID vaccination mandates, and Smith clearly does not need to enact any new passport system. 

But it is also worrisome for a premier to present such clear blocks in opposition to new vaccination guidelines for anyone, ought to the virus evolve additional or another new virus emerge that a vaccine can firmly mitigate, mentioned Saxinger.

When the brand new premier pledged no extra lockdowns, at a time when no person within the Western world was imposing COVID restrictions on eating places or locations of worship, she was making a promise that might solely have penalties if issues tipped again into excessive pandemic peril. But it is not the identical in any respect along with her plans for the Alberta Human Rights Act. 

Given how far-reaching such a transfer would be, you do not have to be a COVID pessimist to be involved it might put lives in danger.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here