Edmonton man could see private data of other Brinks customers through his home security system — for months


Andrew Kopp was having bother with the door sensors on his new Brinks home security system.

The Edmonton man — a methods architect for a telecommunications firm and self-professed gadget fanatic — had added slightly further home security when, in October 2021, he signed a 36-month contract for a Brinks system.

But issues took an odd flip when he known as technical assist to troubleshoot these wonky door sensors. 

He instructed Go Public he signed into his system’s on-line portal “and that is after I observed that I had a drop-down [menu] to pick out an entire bunch of addresses.” 

There on his display screen have been roughly 100 other customers’ addresses.

Every click on of the mouse revealed extra of another person’s info: title, deal with, telephone quantity, emergency contacts and account fee historical past.

  • Got a narrative you need investigated? Contact Carolyn and the Go Public group

Kopp could even view particular issues about other customers’ home security methods, like security tools particulars and areas of security zones inside their properties.

“My response is, [this is] form of insane. I actually do not feel that they are safeguarding other folks’s info,” he stated. 

“I wished to know whether or not my data was compromised in the identical means.” 

That stays unclear. Though Kopp didn’t see his personal particulars on the display screen, Brinks has not notified any of the customers who have been affected by the leak, which went unfixed for months. 

Brinks says no monetary or banking data was included within the leak. 

Privacy skilled Ann Cavoukian says the corporate’s poor response to the issue makes her ‘cringe.’ (Submitted by Ann Cavoukian)

‘Very critical’ breach

But one skilled says it was nonetheless a “very critical privateness breach.”

“Of course, it is a breach of security as properly,” stated Ann Cavoukian, a former three-term privateness commissioner of Ontario. 

“It permits folks to probably break into your home and into your info on-line. Identity theft could end result.”

Kopp assumed the breach could be rapidly mounted after he found and reported it in early 2022. In April, he was shocked to search out out he nonetheless had entry to the identical drop-down menu with the identical buyer info.

He says he reported it once more, waited a number of extra months, and known as Brinks but once more in early July. 

Kopp bought a recording of that decision. In it, he clearly says the problem must be escalated: “I’m going to wish a supervisor,” he instructed the agent as he defined that he was in a position to entry others’ data. 

“It’s an enormous buyer info downside, which is why I would like to talk to a supervisor.”

He was promised a supervisor would name him again, however he bought no response till Go Public started investigating.

“Nobody contacted me concerning a data breach in any respect,” he says.

That makes Cavoukian “cringe.”

“It simply makes me so indignant that this kind of infringement is not taken severely, accurately instantly acted upon,” she stated. 

Brinks declined an interview request from Go Public. In an announcement, the corporate stated the agent on the July name, who labored for a 3rd get together, “didn’t observe the right protocols and procedures” for when a buyer asks for an issue to be escalated. 

“We have since bolstered our protocols and trainings with the consultant in query to make sure compliance with our escalation procedures.”

Prof. Teresa Scassa of the University of Ottawa says corporations are required to report such leaks to the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. (Submitted by Teresa Scassa)

It was not clear what occurred after any of Kopp’s earlier calls.

Brinks provided no clarification for the trigger of the issue, although it indicated it was an error and never the end result of a hack. 

The firm known as it an “deserted situation” that leaked the data of “a small subset” of its customers. “No banking or monetary info was seen,” it stated. 

Brinks didn’t reply Go Public’s query of what number of of its Canadian customers have been affected.

The firm stated the delicate data was seen to “lower than .01% of Brinks whole buyer base.” Brink has some 900,000 home and industrial security subscribers in line with a 2021 company press launch, which works out to about 90 customers. 

A white woman with straight auburn hair wearing glasses and a black blazer--Go Public reporter Carolyn Dunn--  sits at a white desk pressing the key pad of a desk phone in front of her.
Go Public’s Carolyn Dunn calls one of the other Brinks customers whose info was been leaked. None of them had been knowledgeable of the leak by the corporate. (Colin Hall/CBC)

Obliged to report

It wasn’t till virtually two and a half months later, in mid-September, that Kopp noticed that it gave the impression to be mounted. He estimates he was in a position to entry other customers’ data for seven to 10 months.

But Teresa Scassa, Canada Research Chair in Information Law and Policy on the University of Ottawa, says that will not shut the guide on Brinks’s obligations.

“If the corporate is conscious that there is been a data security breach, then they’re obliged to report that to the Privacy Commissioner of Canada,” she stated. 

Brinks didn’t reply Go Public’s query whether or not it notified the privateness commissioner. But Kopp did.

His formal criticism is now making its means through the system. He additionally contacted the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner in Alberta.

The Alberta workplace instructed Go Public will probably be contacting Brinks “to remind them of their obligation to report back to our workplace and notify affected people.” 

Scassa says reporting to the federal privateness commissioner might also set off a requirement to inform affected customers. She says corporations with info breaches generally supply helps equivalent to credit score monitoring companies to mitigate the danger to their customers and assist defend towards class-action lawsuits they could face.

A woman with short dark hair dyed vivid blue on one side sits on a green sofa and faces the camera.
Aimee Scott of Okanagan Falls, B.C., says she was unnerved to be taught in regards to the leak. (Tom Popyk/CBC)

“An organization would ignore one thing like this at their very own peril. There’s no ‘it did not occur’ if it did. If it did, it’s important to get out in entrance of it and repair it.”

Brinks stated that its personal evaluate with inside and exterior counsel concluded: “The nature of the data that was seen didn’t require a buyer notification.”

Kopp determined it wasn’t “applicable” for him to contact these customers. So Go Public made the calls, contacting a number of who had proven up on Kopp’s portal.

None had been notified by Brinks that something had occurred with their data, together with Aimee Scott of Okanagan Falls, B.C.

“The factor that bothered me, or I suppose was a bit unnerving is the truth that I by no means heard from Brinks about it,” Scott stated.

Scott says she’s in a position to perceive a technical glitch, however she’s not glad that sufficient was completed.

“It’s disconcerting. I imply, issues occur. But I imply, attain out and let folks know that it is occurred and come clean with it.” 

As for Kopp — he is questioning if he is actually getting what he signed up for.

“It worries me as a result of I paid for a security firm as a result of I wished security, and so they cannot safeguard my private info, by no means thoughts every little thing else,” he stated. 

WATCH | Kopp says he is now involved in regards to the security of his private info: 

Online glitch allowed Edmonton man to see private data of other Brinks customers

An Edmonton man says a web-based glitch gave him entry to the private info of dozens of Brinks Home Security customers. But when he tried to report the problem, nobody known as him again.

Submit your story concepts

Go Public is an investigative information phase on CBC-TV, radio and the net.

We inform your tales, make clear wrongdoing and maintain the powers that be accountable.

If you’ve gotten a narrative within the public curiosity, or for those who’re an insider with info, contact GoPublic@cbc.ca together with your title, contact info and a short abstract. All emails are confidential till you resolve to Go Public.

Follow @CBCGoPublic on Twitter.

Read extra tales by Go Public.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here