Municipal elections: Anti-hate group warns of school board trustee candidates


It’s municipal election season, and specialists are warning that some far-right teams and people are bringing an agenda of anti-diversity and anti-LGBTQ2S+ views to an vital, however often-forgotten, poll battleground: school boards.

According to the Canadian Anti-Hate Network (CAHN), far-right lobbying teams are trying to put in school board trustees who will uphold what CAHN calls regressive views.

Those they’re warning towards say they’re merely making an attempt to tell Canadians the place school board candidates stand on sure points.

But CAHN says that pushing candidates who assist what it calls hateful ideologies can have massively unfavorable impacts on school environments, from creating unsafe insurance policies exposing LGBTQ2S+ college students in entrance of doubtlessly unsupportive households to voting to restrict books and audio system that might present college students with extra various views.

“The outcomes finally, are very damaging,” Hazel Woodrow, an schooling facilitator with CAHN, instructed in a cellphone interview. “So regardless of what they variety of declare, or their motivations, finally, the outcomes are usually not in the most effective pursuits of college students and particularly, marginalized college students.”

CAHN initially posted a launch concerning the difficulty in late August, warning that the “far-right is making an attempt to stack school boards.”

The unbiased group, which was began in 2018, is a “non-profit non-partisan group that screens, researches, exposes far proper and hate selling teams, actions, people in Canada,” in keeping with Woodrow.

CAHN obtained a grant via the federal authorities’s Anti-Racism Action Program in 2020 to create an anti-racism toolkit for faculties, however shouldn’t be at the moment receiving any authorities funds.

The Campaign Life Coalition (CLC), a pro-life group which CAHN calls a “reactionary far-right lobbying group,” frequently pushes for its members to run for school boards, “and has been endorsing political candidates for over 20 years.”

The director of political operations wrote in a July weblog submit that it’s vital to “elect God-fearing school trustees” who will attempt to steer faculties to show that abortion and LGBTQ2S+ identities are a “grave sin.”

They endorse candidates in each Catholic and public school board races. Within the general public school board system in Ontario alone, there are 89 candidates that CLC “deems supportable,” Woodrow stated, underlining how huge the problem is.

Across Canada, “it’s probably in the hundreds, at least,” she stated.

Since it first raised this difficulty, CAHN has additionally been tallying candidates in races throughout the nation on its web site who it alleges are half of this far-right push, starting from candidates who’re allegedly related to white supremacy teams such because the Proud Boys to candidates who’ve been overtly racist, homophobic and transphobic.

Some of the candidates it has flagged have come underneath fireplace from most people as properly. In August, two school board trustee candidates from Ottawa made information for espousing anti-trans views, sparking backlash from dad and mom and activists.

British Columbia and Yukon already held their elections earlier this month, however subsequent week there are two provinces holding their municipal elections: Ontario on Oct. 24 and Manitoba on Oct. 26.

On Nov. 7, Prince Edward Island residents will probably be heading to the poll field.

Far-right is a broad time period refers to those that are on the intense proper finish of the political spectrum. Far-right teams typically have a heavy concentrate on nationalism and might even see completely different marginalized teams as threats, akin to girls, racial minorities, and people within the LGBTQ2S+ neighborhood.


When it comes time for native elections, most individuals will know which mayoral candidate they’re inquisitive about voting for, and will even have paid consideration to their native metropolis councillor race.

But school board trustees typically get forgotten — a typical “downballot” downside, Woodrow stated.

“I think a lot of people assume that they don’t need to be invested in these races, if they don’t have kids in the school system,” she stated.

Schools are shaping the subsequent technology, nevertheless, and school board trustees, because the connection between the neighborhood and the school, can play a giant position in that.

“They create, they develop, they enforce policies that shape the school and environment,” Woodrow stated.

A school board dominated by anti-LGBTQ2S+ trustees might create insurance policies that expose college students to violence or harassment.

“An example of that might be a policy that requires school staff to inform the students’ caregivers of their participation in something like a Queer Straight Alliance, which could risk outing the student to a household that could be hostile to their identity,” Woodrow identified.

But there may be extra delicate repercussions too.

Before CLC endorses a candidate, it has them fill out a questionnaire. In one query that CLC poses to Catholic school board candidates, it asks if candidates will stop visitor audio system who’ve “publicly expressed positions that contradict the morality and teaching of the Church, no matter how great their achievements in politics, business, sports, science or the arts.”

This signifies that even when a homosexual man have been invited as a school speaker purely to share his profession as an astronaut, for instance, a school board trustee accepted by CLC would vote towards permitting this.

“Basically they’re saying, no matter how accomplished someone is, if they are even passively expressing a ‘position’ by marrying someone of the same gender, or transitioning, that would be someone who is not allowed to come into the classroom,” Woodrow stated.

“(It’s) preventing queer and trans students from seeing queer and trans adults in their school community living openly and thriving. I see that (as) a more passive and insidious way of denying them that.”

In an e-mail assertion to, Matthew Wojciechowski, vice-president of CLC, stated it’s “informing Canadians on where school board candidates stand on issues that are important to them.”

When requested about endorsing candidates who espouse anti-LGBTQ2s+ views, Wojciechowski acknowledged that CLC joins “countless parents and grandparents across Canada … in upholding a respect for life, the safeguarding of male-female marriage, the protection of the nuclear family, and the loving defence of every person created in the image of God as ‘male or female.’”

This anti-LGBTQ2S+ rhetoric is threaded all through the questions that it poses within the questionnaire it sends to public school board candidates as properly.

One query for this group is whether or not candidates imagine dad and mom have the “right to withdraw their children from classroom lessons or presentations involving controversial issues such as abortion, contraception and homosexuality”.

Schools being protected environments for all youngsters is a public well being difficulty, Woodrow stated.

“There is really robust evidence that shows that when (queer and transgender) young people are in affirming and validating environments … they have far better mental health outcomes, including reduced risk of self-harm and suicide,” she stated.

“So we consider these issues to be public health issues, ultimately, and we consider that queer and trans youth have the right to health, and that’s a right that Canada has affirmed through the UN Declaration on the rights of a child. We think that it is a violation of those rights to be advocating for school environments that are intentionally non-affirming.”

Woodrow stated that over the previous few months, she and the CAHN group have been researching school board candidates in races throughout the nation.

Some purple flags are if candidates have overtly made racist or anti-trans statements, she stated, or if a sitting trustee has persistently voted towards insurance policies that promote range and fairness. Repeating conspiracies can be a “red alert” as a result of “there’s so much overlap between hate ideologies and conspiracism,” she added.

CLC can, mockingly, be a useful supply for CAHN attributable to its questionnaire making it clear who might create what CAHN feels is an unsafe school atmosphere, Woodrow says.

On its web site, CLC outlines which candidates it endorses in each race in public and Catholic school boards throughout the nation with a red-to-green site visitors mild score.

“If Campaign Life Coalition has a bunch of really, really flattering things to say about (a candidate), that becomes concerning for us,” Woodrow stated.

CLC pushed again towards CAHN’s characterization of it in its assertion to, with Wojciechowski stating that the group “likes to label anybody who disagrees with them as hateful.

“Disagreement shouldn’t be hate,” he stated.

Woodrow pressured that CAHN is non-partisan, and doesn’t warn towards particular candidates except they’ve what it sees as clear proof of them spreading hateful views.

“In order for us to be covering them, they would have to be pretty hardcore,” she stated.


Another title flagged by CAHN is Blueprint for Canada — a web site which popped up this 12 months, run by Peter Wallace, a school board trustee candidate for Kawartha Lakes, Ont.

The web site — which states that these behind it reject “woke ideology,” advocate for requiring academics to out trans college students to their dad and mom, wish to finish pupil golf equipment based mostly on race or ethnicity, and imagine that educating a defence of European colonialism in school is “controversial” however “necessary” — claims on its homepage to be a shared platform for public schooling coverage that advocates for “moderate centrist policies.”

While Blueprint for Canada shouldn’t be a lobbying group, the web site invitations candidates to endorse its alternate set of coverage positions.

“At its core, Blueprint for Canada seeks to address contemporary social issues around diversity and inclusion in ways that unite Canadians as opposed to dividing them based on their immutable characteristics,” Wallace instructed in an e-mail.

A web page on the web site lists the “positive” impacts of colonialism whereas stressing that “the harm and trauma experienced by Indigenous populations worldwide” shouldn’t be diminished. It additionally alleges that those that don’t train the “positive ways” that colonialism has impacted the world are doing so as a result of they wish to “shame students based on their heritage.”

Woodrow stated this assumption typically displays dad and mom projecting their discomfort with the realities of historical past onto their youngsters.

“As a parent, as an adult, I’m really uncomfortable, and I don’t know how to begin with this guilt that I’m feeling, and they’re projecting that onto their kids and saying, ‘I don’t want my kid to feel like this,’” Woodrow stated.

“Without recognizing how racialized kids feel with not seeing those (realities), and not having those conversations in class and not having those experiences respected and affirmed through their lessons. I think kids are stronger and more curious than a lot of parents give them credit for. And I think that white kids can handle learning this stuff.”

Blueprint for Canada additionally outlined the way it seeks to take away the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion framework in faculties with a Merit, Fairness and Equality framework, advocating for a idea of “racelessness.”

The web site beforehand hosted a listing of endorsed candidates, however took it down after issues have been raised that it might be thought of third-party promoting.

Wallace stated that these behind the positioning weren’t contacted by Elections Canada and that an unbiased authorized counsel suggested them {that a} “shared policy platform of this sort does not constitute 3rd party advertising under the Municipal Elections Act so long as it is not used to endorse or raise funds for any candidate.”

Municipal events and the pooling of sources between candidates in municipal races are curbed by Ontario’s election laws.

“In the end, we opted to remove it mainly to be safe about ensuring compliance with the Municipal Elections Act,” he acknowledged.

Now, as an alternative, Blueprint For Canada hyperlinks to a listing of candidates on a third-party web site known as “Vote Against Woke.”

Wallace stated he has not met the creator of this web site, however has messaged him via Twitter and that he’s a “parent who seems to share my concerns about public education.”

Similarly to CLC, anti-trans views seem like a cornerstone of Blueprint for Canada’s insurance policies, with the web site saying that members think about it “abusive” to affirm trans youngsters, and that academics shouldn’t be allowed to confer with trans college students by their right pronouns with out written consent from dad and mom.

“We fully support the LGB community and have received considerable public support online from members of the LGB community online,” Blueprint for Canada instructed

Wallace clarified within the assertion that he personally considers himself “gender critical,” a time period lately adopted by these with anti-trans views to explain their skepticism within the range of gender.

“I view stereotypical gender behaviours as simply the cultural manifestations of deeply rooted neurological/biological differences in the male/female brain,” he stated. “These are most likely due to millions of years of different evolutionary pressures between the two sexes.”

He added that that is “the one difficulty that seems to be resonating overwhelmingly in our favour with the general public in door-to-door campaigning.”

“We may well win our campaigns on this one issue alone,” he stated.

It’s a chilling assertion to Woodrow.

There are a number of “vectors of radicalization,” she stated, including that specialists in hate teams acknowledge anti-trans sentiment as one of the important thing ones.

“I would say misogyny and anti-semitism are also key vectors, but it is across the board, every single hate movement that we cover is trans antagonistic,” she stated. “Extremely so.

“The people who are pushing the trans antagonism will not stop with excising trans people from society. It would be on its own awful enough if that’s what it was.”

But anti-trans sentiment is tied up in attitudes in direction of gender roles and in direction of the LGBTQ2S+ neighborhood as a complete, Woodrow stated, and he or she believes it received’t cease there.

“They’re seeking to turn back protections and the social discourse that has been won through struggle over the last 20 years for all queer people, and then subsequently for women, for racialized people,” Woodrow stated. “I don’t want to make it sound like this will happen sequentially, because it is all happening at the same time. It’s just sort of happening most loudly and grotesquely to trans people in this moment.”

In its assertion to, Blueprint for Canada tried to say that CAHN itself is “extensively regarded to be a hate group.”

Canada would not have one centralized definition of a hate group, however it’s an indictable offense to “incite hatred” in direction of an “identifiable group” as outlined in Canada’s Criminal Code.

According to Section 318 of the Criminal Code, “identifiable group” refers to “any part of the general public distinguished by color, race, faith, nationwide or ethnic origin, age, intercourse, sexual orientation, gender id or expression, or psychological or bodily incapacity.”

CLC is a company that CAHN has been monitoring for some time, however the existence of new web sites like Blueprint for Canada which might be seemingly taking cues from CLC are additionally a trigger for concern for the group, Woodrow stated.

“They’re both concerning because they are ultimately both seeking to make schools less inclusive and equitable and overall less safe for marginalized students,” she stated.


Woodrow acknowledged that it may be troublesome for folks to kind via all of the conflicting details about school board trustees and coverage positions with the intention to work out what’s finest for his or her baby, significantly for many who aren’t heavy information readers or who don’t get entangled in politics often and will miss purple flags or dogwhistles.

A web page on the CAHN web site outlines questions that oldsters might pose to school board trustee candidates to get an thought for his or her positions — just like the thought behind CLC’s questionnaire, however with a “children’s rights framework” in thoughts, in keeping with website.

“The purpose of that is we want to make engaging in this political process as easy and as accessible as we possibly can,” she stated. “The far right does this extremely, extremely well. They’ve got all these databases, they’ve got questionnaires and quizzes and so we’re trying to help it be as easy as possible for people to engage in this process.”

Ultimately, what each dad or mum desires is a protected and supportive atmosphere at school for his or her youngsters — and when some youngsters are usually not protected at school as a result of they’re being focused by racist or transphobic insurance policies, that’s not a protected atmosphere for the remaining of the scholars both, Woodrow stated.

She was raised in “pretty far-right, traditionalist Catholicism” herself and says it was troublesome for her as a queer individual in a small city. She doesn’t need youngsters to need to undergo what she did.

“I am really invested in creating and contributing to the creation of school environments that would be that I would have wanted to and deserved to be in as a young person,” she stated. “That’s the kind of school that I want to help all voters create within their own communities.” 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here