‘Nothing short of dangerous’: Vuntut Gwitchin calls for public inquiry into release of sex offender


The Vuntut Gwitchin authorities says Yukon’s justice system has failed its residents and put them in danger after the Yukon Territorial Court ordered a sex offender to be launched on bail to Old Crow, Yukon.

The First Nation additionally desires a public inquiry into all of the elements that led to the court docket’s choice to release Christopher Russel Schafer.

Schafer, 45, has a prison historical past of violent sexual assaults and different assaults spanning greater than 20 years, together with a vicious assault in Old Crow in 1999. He additionally has current costs of assault, forcible confinement and uttering threats in Whitehorse. He is at present nonetheless in custody within the Whitehorse Correctional Centre. 

On Friday, a Justice of the Peace agreed to a release plan for Schafer that may see him fly to his distant residence neighborhood of Old Crow.

According to Vuntut Gwitchin Chief Dana Tizya-Tramm, the neighborhood was blindsided by that call. He says the neighborhood had at some point’s discover of Schafer’s return.

“I feel like many others in our neighborhood, my voice escaped me for a minute,” Tizya-Tramm stated of his response to the information of the court docket order.

“Soon after, my coronary heart dropped as a result of I knew there was going to be loads of ache — ache for the household, ache throughout the neighborhood.”

A highway in Old Crow, Yukon pictured on July 22, 2022. An indication studying “Welcome to Old Crow” hooked up to a log cabin is seen on the proper, together with the neighborhood’s water therapy facility within the background. (Jackie Hong/CBC)

The small city of about 250 individuals has simply two RCMP officers, no medical doctors and no psychological well being professionals.

Tizya-Tramm stated the court docket order set the neighborhood on edge. The Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation shortly declared a state of emergency to make it unlawful for Schafer to set foot on its lands.

The matter was again in court docket on Tuesday afternoon however left unresolved.

Crown lawyer William McDiarmid informed court docket on Tuesday that the plan for Schafer’s release was an “ostensibly cheap plan” as of final week. The First Nation’s emergency order modified that, McDiarmid stated.

The Crown argued Tuesday that Schafer ought to now stay in jail lest he violate both his release plan — which requires him to reside at an handle in Old Crow — or the First Nation’s order banning him from the neighborhood. 

McDiarmid and defence lawyer Nora Mooney stated discussions have been underway to determine an alternate release plan. 

Yukon Territorial Court Chief Judge Michael Cozens, earlier than setting Schafer’s subsequent court docket date for Wednesday, stated there was “loads of misinformation on the market” in regards to the state of affairs and famous Schafer, as of Friday, hadn’t been underneath any court docket orders barring him from returning to Old Crow.

‘Deep insensitivity’ 

Speaking to media after Tuesday’s court docket proceedings in Whitehorse, Tizya-Tramm stated his neighborhood is just not prepared for Schafer to be “launched” into their midst. He blasted the justice system’s “deep insensitivity” for making such a choice with out informing or involving the First Nation.

“This is nothing short of harmful,” Tizya-Tramm stated, flanked by Kwanlin Dün First Nation Chief Doris Bill.

“This flies within the face of nationwide inquiries into lacking and murdered Indigenous ladies and women.”

Tizya-Tramm stated the Vuntut Gwitchin made its place identified a yr in the past that folks with a prison historical past like Schafer’s shouldn’t be returned to the neighborhood. He stated the First Nation had been working with neighborhood members, together with Schafer’s household, to develop a reintegration plan for Schafer.

Last week’s release order ignored all of that, Tizya-Tramm stated.

“The neighborhood is open to having Mr. Schafer, however there needs to be a course of,” he stated.

Searching for accountability

Tizya-Tramm additionally despatched a letter to federal Justice Minister David Lametti on Tuesday, looking for “accountability from these accountable for the continuing colonial violence towards ladies and women inside Canadian society together with because it continues to be perpetuated by the Canadian authorized system.”

The letter lists a quantity of calls for to “meaningfully redress the hurt and trauma that has been inflicted by the release order,” together with a public apology to Old Crow and the Vuntut Gwitchin residents.

It additionally says a public inquiry is required, to find out the “direct and systemic elements” that led to the release order, and calls for counselling companies and different wellness helps for any Vuntut Gwitchin residents affected by the release order.

Bonnie Bingham, a councillor with the Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation, stated Old Crow nonetheless hasn’t recovered from the harm Schafer has achieved up to now.

“There remains to be unresolved previous trauma from the actions of this specific man, and there hasn’t been sufficient work to deal with and heal the neighborhood,” she stated.

‘Scrambling to seek out helps’

The emergency measure, which additionally bans anybody from serving to Schafer to remain on Vuntut Gwitchin lands, brings a penalty of as much as six months in jail for those that violate it.

Tizya-Tramm stated his concern is not simply for his neighborhood — it is for Schafer as properly.

“To simply don’t have any reintegration, and to instantly simply hurl this particular person into the center of a neighborhood … is just not conducive to reintegration,” he stated.

“It’s not OK in nearly each means you have a look at it, and now I discover myself scrambling to seek out helps for Mr. Schafer, as … he very properly could also be homeless.”

Tizya-Tramm stated the Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation has up to now tried to reintegrate Schafer into Old Crow. In July and August of 2021, the First Nation let the neighborhood know Schafer was because of be launched, he stated, and had Schafer do an area radio present.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here