Price gap on heavy Canadian oil tops $30 per barrel, widest spread since 2018


A barrel of the North American oil benchmark is altering fingers for about $90 US a barrel proper now, however the heavy crude that comes from Canada’s oilsands is fetching $30 much less due to an ideal storm of imbalances between provide and demand.

The oil mix often called West Texas Intermediate (WTI) was going for about $87 a barrel on Thursday. That’s down from latest highs, however nonetheless way over the value supplied for each barrel of crude oil from Canada’s oilsands, a thick, tarry, and “bitter” kind of crude that goes by the identify Western Canada Select (WCS).

WCS was fetching just a little over $53 US a barrel on Thursday, the most affordable degree it has been since Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, which pushed oil costs to their highest degree in years on fears of a wider battle, and despatched international locations scrambling to interchange sanctioned Russian crude.​

It’s additionally greater than $34 per barrel cheaper than WTI, which is the widest gap between the 2 blends since 2018.

Western Canada Select virtually all the time sells at a reduction to WTI, as a result of solely a relatively small variety of refineries are able to dealing with it. It’s usually seen to be of decrease high quality due to its excessive sulphur content material, which makes it a “bitter” mix, versus a “sweeter” mix like WTI. That means refineries need to be calibrated in a sure means simply to course of it, which pushes down the value of WCS to offset that added price.

Then there’s the price of transport it from Northern Alberta to refineries within the United States, which even below superb circumstances add one other $5 to $10 low cost on the value of each barrel. Oil is priced in U.S. {dollars} as a result of like many commodities together with gold, the market is worldwide.

Pipelines aren’t accountable this time

Drum-tight pipeline capability is generally accountable any time the spread between the 2 oil blends is as extensive as it’s proper now, however specialists say that is not the case this time round.

Instead, there are fewer patrons for WCS as a result of a number of refineries that course of it are offline in the meanwhile. And there’s decreased demand for oil total due to fears a recession is coming. 

Add all of it up and it is an ideal storm of explanation why the underside has fallen out of Canada’s oil worth, mentioned Vijay Muralidharan, director, R Cube Economic Consulting Inc. “Demand is falling and when demand falls the differential widens,” he instructed CBC News in an interview.

Fall is usually the season when refineries shut themselves right down to carry out upkeep, however there’s much more refineries than regular offline proper now, as a result of unplanned shutdowns. A 160,000-barrel-per-day refinery in Toledo, Ohio, was shut down as a result of a fireplace in August, and whereas it reopened final month, it isn’t but again to full capability. 

An even larger one in Whiting, Ind., close to Chicago, usually processes 430,000 barrels of oil per day, however it, too, was knocked offline by a fireplace, and it has additionally but to get again to regular. 

“Plenty of Canadian heavy crude goes to that refinery and if it goes off it is a huge hit to WCS,” Muralidharan mentioned. So Canadian crude that will usually be refined someplace round Chicago is having to journey additional afield to get processed.

Barges idle whereas ready for passage within the Mississippi River close to Vicksburg, Miss., on Tuesday, Oct. 4, 2022. The unusually low water degree within the decrease Mississippi River is inflicting barges to get caught within the muddy river backside, leading to delays. (Thomas Berner/The Associated Press)

Mississippi River barges exacerbating the issue

Some of it will usually journey by river, however that route can also be a part of the issue proper now due to abnormally low water ranges on the Mississippi River, mentioned Rory Johnston, founding father of the Commodity Context publication.

“They usually barge a bunch of those merchandise out [but] the Mississippi is operating very dry so there’s considerations about bottlenecks and transport there as nicely,” he mentioned in an interview.

At least a half dozen barges on the Mississippi have been grounded prior to now week, the U.S. coast guard says, inflicting transport delays and considerations that extra might get caught. One of the outcomes of that bottleneck is that refineries that rely on the river to usher in crude and ship out product are briefly shedding their urge for food for Canadian oil.

“The low degree of the Mississippi does appear to be weighing on WCS costs, given the availability dislocations it’s inflicting,” oil analyst Matt Smith with Kpler instructed CBC News in an e-mail. “Refineries are seemingly having to dial again on exercise as a result of they’re unable to maneuver merchandise.”

That decreased demand for Canadian crude is spreading from Chicago to each a part of the complicated oil provide chain.

“We’re truly seeing the weak spot lengthen all the best way right down to the US Gulf Coast,” Johnston mentioned.

There’s greater than sufficient pipeline capability to get oil wherever it must go in the meanwhile. But even as soon as these WCS barrels get to the various refineries across the U.S. Gulf Coast, they’re then confronted with their subsequent drawback: The Biden administration has been releasing thousands and thousands of barrels from the nation’s Strategic Petroleum Reserve, as a way to offset the tumult attributable to Putin’s invasion.

Those barrels of WCS are sloshing round in the identical refinery hub as these American barrels, looking for a purchaser. And all that crude is beginning to pile up. Data from the EIA on Wednesday confirmed the full variety of barrels of oil in storage within the U.S. elevated by virtually 10 million barrels final week. 

That means demand is waning, which is a common sign the financial system is slowing — which implies oil costs will face an uphill climb even below superb circumstances.

“The excellent news right here is that this does not look like associated to inadequate pipeline capability for Canadian oil. The dangerous information is that it is one thing virtually fully outdoors of our management proper now,” Johnston mentioned.

“It does not appear to be getting higher but. So there’s an open query how dangerous this may get.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here