‘There was no plan’: Ottawa police floundered as convoy protest grew


On Friday, Feb. 4, Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) Supt. Craig Abrams was at his command put up watching Ottawa’s then chief of police Peter Sloly converse to reporters on reside TV.

It was the eve of what was anticipated to be a second weekend of mayhem within the capital, with tons of, maybe 1000’s of anti-vaccine mandate and anti-government protesters able to descend on town to affix these already encamped downtown, creating what Sloly described as an progressively unstable and doubtlessly harmful surroundings.

What actually caught Abrams’s ear was Sloly’s announcement that based mostly on “new intelligence gathered actually within the final 24 hours,” police deliberate to close down all ramps from Highway 417 main into town.

Ontario Provincial Police Supt. Craig Abrams testified earlier than the Public Order Emergency Commission in Ottawa on Thursday, Oct. 20. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

As one of many provincial power’s most senior officers within the area, and the OPP’s strategic commander throughout final winter’s convoy protest, Abrams was stunned to listen to in regards to the plan, notably for the reason that OPP has jurisdiction over each the freeway and the ramps that may quickly need to be closed.

Abrams, a 27-year police veteran, knew he had neither the time nor the assets to execute the chief’s plan.

“It induced me nice concern,” he testified Thursday earlier than the general public inquiry into the federal authorities’s eventual use of the Emergencies Act to finish the occupation. “It was completely out of the blue. [I was] unprepared and unaware.”

OPP Superintendent Craig Abrams describes police officers yelling ‘profanities’ at one another throughout convoy protest

Abrams says a report he obtained described police officers yelling profanities at one another and indicators that their leaders had misplaced management.

‘This was the chief’s thought’

Abrams texted Ottawa Police Service (OPS) Deputy Chief Steve Bell, who had been standing behind Sloly throughout the announcement.

“He indicated that there was no new intelligence, and there was no plan to shut ramps,” Abrams advised the fee.

Perplexed, Abrams double-checked with the OPP’s important incident commander on the National Capital Region Command Centre (NCRCC), the place municipal, provincial and federal police pooled their assets.

“They had been by no means even notified. This was the chief’s thought,” Abrams stated.

OPP officers at a checkpoint on Metcalfe Street on Feb. 19. (Justin Tang/The Canadian Press)

It was simply certainly one of many troubling accounts heard on the inquiry final week that illustrated the obvious lack of any cohesive, sensible plan to finish the siege for practically two weeks.

While the fee’s actual function is to find out whether or not the choice to invoke the particular powers out there below the act was justified, the early testimony and paperwork which were entered into proof have additionally lifted the veil on the confusion, dysfunction and distrust that existed among the many prime ranks of the OPS — an environment that will have contributed to the delay in any efficient police response to the disaster.

No Plan B, both

Abrams testified that as early as the primary weekend, OPP dispatched a small contingent of public order officers to Ottawa to assist the OPS regain management, however that on at the least one event, most of them sat round OPS headquarters on Elgin Street with out being deployed. 

By that Monday, when it was turning into clear, as prior intelligence had forewarned, that many protesters had been digging in moderately than heading dwelling, Ottawa police, whose command was both unaware of or unconcerned by that data, had been scrambling to determine how one can take care of what Sloly was already calling an occupation.

“I simply needed to assume that Ottawa had a capability to handle what might have been a longer-term occasion, that there will need to have been a Plan B,” Abrams testified.

He quickly found there wasn’t.

A web page from Ottawa police deputy chief Trish Ferguson’s journal, entered into proof on the Public Order Emergency Commission, describes the response of the police liaison staff to arrests at Coventry Road on Feb. 6. ‘PLT is pissed — OPP has left.’ (Public Order Emergency Commission)

When Sloly introduced a “surge and include” technique towards the top of the primary week, Abrams, involved for the security of his members, balked.

“These had been concepts and ideas of what they needed to occur, but when it did not include a plan, I definitely wasn’t going to supply OPP assist,” he advised the fee. “There needed to be a cogent plan for that to occur, and up up to now I nonetheless hadn’t seen one.”

Crackdown at Coventry

On Feb. 6, a police liaison staff (PLT) of OPS and OPP officers entered the protest encampment on Coventry Road, the place there have been rising considerations that the baseball stadium car parking zone was getting used as an unlawful — and doubtlessly harmful — gas distribution centre.

The “smooth hat” method had labored up to now to diffuse tense conditions, and the PLT had already made restricted inroads with organizers. But when some protesters started to depart the encampment, police officers below the command of Supt. Mark Patterson — the third senior OPS officer to carry that place in three days — swooped in and began laying fees.

According to OPS Deputy Chief Trish Ferguson, who additionally testified Thursday, Patterson was desperate to “get some wins” to reveal to the general public that police had been taking motion.

Instead, the largely fruitless crackdown solely broken the tenuous belief that existed between police and protest leaders, and sparked the departure of the OPP’s PLT.

Former Ottawa police chief Peter Sloly, proper, steps away to permit Deputy Chief Steve Bell to reply a query at a information convention on Feb. 4. (Justin Tang/The Canadian Press)

“PLT is pissed. OPP has left. Set us again days or per week,” Ferguson jotted in her notes, entered into proof on the fee.

Shortly after that incident, as it grew to become progressively apparent that OPS had been floundering on their very own, senior officers from OPP, RCMP and quite a few different police businesses arrived in Ottawa to kind an built-in command and give you a workable plan to finish the protest.

According to Ferguson, Sloly was sad. 

“He gave the impression to be suspicious of why they had been right here,” she testified. “I feel he was feeling examined.”

Chief ‘searching for motion’

By Feb. 9, there was nonetheless no complete OPS technique to finish the occupation, in line with Abrams. That afternoon, the built-in planning staff was known as to a different tense assembly at Elgin Street.

“Chief Sloly was searching for motion,” Abrams testified.

Patterson produced a listing of “dynamic actions,” certainly one of which was a plan to clear the intersection of Rideau Street and Sussex Drive, the place a contingent of uncooperative protesters police intelligence suspected of getting ties to bikers and extremists from Quebec remained entrenched. The operation was to happen at 11 p.m. that night time.

Abrams requested for specifics, such as how they might take away the vehicles from the intersection, and was advised by Patterson that retired OPS officers is likely to be employed to drive them away, or army gear might be used to tow them. Neither choice appeared reasonable, and Abrams knew the plan, which he described as “two strains on a web page,” was flimsy at greatest.

Parked vehicles occupy the intersection of Rideau Street and MacKenzie Avenue in Ottawa on Feb. 6. A swiftly drafted plan by Ottawa police to clear the realm a number of days later was known as off, in line with testimony this week on the Public Order Emergency Commission. (Reno Patry/CBC)

He additionally had considerations that police liaison officers hadn’t been engaged to seek out out whether or not there have been kids within the vehicles, and stated such tactical operations ought to by no means be carried out at nighttime.

“I advised [Patterson] immediately … based mostly on what I’m seeing and what I’ve simply heard, you’ll by no means see OPP assist for any operation tonight or tomorrow,” Abrams stated. “I needed to ask the questions as a result of it was harmful for our members.”

That operation was deserted, and it could take one other 11 days to finish the occupation. Sloly resigned on Feb. 15.

The fee resumes Monday, when extra senior OPP and OPS officers will testify, together with Bell. Sloly is predicted to look later within the week.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here