Why there’s excitement and skepticism about new Alzheimer’s drug lecanemab


This is an excerpt from Second Opinion, a weekly evaluation of well being and medical science information emailed to subscribers. If you have not subscribed, you are able to do that by clicking right here.

Despite a long time of analysis and billions of {dollars}, no therapy has ever definitively confirmed to sluggish the development of Alzheimer’s illness.

Two pharmaceutical corporations have developed a drug that they are saying does simply that.

On Tuesday, the total outcomes of a worldwide human trial of the drug, referred to as lecanemab, will likely be launched at an Alzheimer’s analysis convention in San Francisco.

The corporations — Biogen of the U.S. and Eisai of Japan — have thus far merely summarized the outcomes of the human trial in a September information launch. It stated early-stage Alzheimer’s illness sufferers who obtained lecanemab over the research’s 18-month timeframe scored 27 per cent higher on cognitive assessments than those that’d obtained a placebo.

More than 600,000 Canadians reside with dementia, and Alzheimer’s illness is the most typical type. The Alzheimer’s Society of Canada forecasts that quantity to achieve a million by 2030.

While some specialists say there may be loads of optimism to be discovered about lecanemab’s potential, different have cautions and questions: What will the total information reveal? How a lot will the drug value? How lengthy can it stave off the devastating results of Alzheimer’s illness, which may embody extreme recollection loss, mood modifications and the lack to carry out fundamental duties. 

Roughly translated, the outcomes counsel lecanemab slowed the advance of Alzheimer’s illness in its early levels by four-to-five months over the 18-month interval of the research.

“We’ve had many failures and disappointments in drug growth on this illness,” stated Dr. Sharon Cohen, medical director of the Toronto Memory Clinic, one of many human trial websites for lecanemab.

Dr. Sharon Cohen, pictured right here Nov. 17, is a neurologist and medical director of the Toronto Memory Clinic, the place she oversaw a part of the human trial of lecanemab. (Turgut Yeter/CBC)

“This is a really hopeful time in Alzheimer’s illness,” Cohen stated in an interview with CBC News. “We have, for the primary time, a chance to decelerate a nasty illness at an early stage when persons are nonetheless functioning properly.”

Cohen will likely be one of many researchers presenting the lecanemab information on Tuesday on the Clinical Trials on Alzheimer’s Disease convention.

“Any slowing of illness — if what you are doing at the moment you are still doing in six months or a yr — that is a win, as a result of we all know this illness is relentless,” Cohen stated. “We haven’t been capable of cease it from progressing beforehand.”

‘Some huge cash for 27 per cent enchancment’

The information launch by Biogen and Eisai described the discovering that the drug slowed cognitive decline by 27 per cent as “extremely statistically important.”

But some are questioning how important that will be for folks dwelling with early-stage Alzheimer’s.

Dr. John Forsayeth, a professor emeritus of neurosurgery on the University of California in San Francisco who has labored with biotechnology corporations within the seek for Alzheimer’s therapies, is skeptical about lecanemab. 

“I do not suppose it is within the health-care system’s curiosity to spend … some huge cash for a 27 per cent enchancment,” stated Forsayeth in an interview. “If it actually had a big impact then you might make an argument.”

While the value of lecanemab has not been introduced, an identical drug referred to as aducanumab — additionally developed by Biogen and Eisai — hit the market final yr at a price of $56,000 US per yr.

WATCH | Debate over dangers and advantages of Aduhelm:

Debating the dangers, advantages of a controversial Alzheimer drug

There’s debate over whether or not Canada ought to comply with the U.S.’s lead and approve a controversial drug to deal with Alzheimer’s, regardless of issues Aducanumab isn’t efficient and may be dangerous. But the uncertainty isn’t stopping some sufferers from desirous to strive the remedy.

Much of the wariness amongst specialists about the new drug from Biogen and Eisai stems from what occurred simply final yr with aducanumab, bought underneath the commerce identify Aduhelm.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration gave Aduhelm accelerated approval in June 2021, regardless of little-to-no proof that it truly slowed the development of Alzheimer’s. (Neither Canadian nor European regulators authorised the drug.)

Aduhelm’s U.S. launch fizzled when many medical health insurance corporations and hospitals balked at paying for the drug, saying it merely wasn’t an efficient therapy. The remaining nail in its coffin got here in January when the U.S. Medicare system refused to cowl it exterior scientific trials.

Biogen and Eisai have additionally submitted lecanemab for accelerated FDA approval and a choice is scheduled for early January.

Is drug’s goal the precise reason behind Alzheimer’s illness?

Lecanemab and aducanumab work in comparable methods. Both are monoclonal antibodies (that is why their names each finish in -mab) and each goal a protein referred to as amyloid.

Because the brains of individuals with Alzheimer’s illness have irregular clumps of this protein round and between neurons, there’s broad scientific consensus that amyloid performs some form of position within the illness.

But there’s no consensus on what precisely that position is.

In the best phrases, the query is whether or not these amyloid clumps are the basis reason behind Alzheimer’s illness or just an impact. Even amongst those that consider amyloid does trigger the illness, there’s debate over exactly how.

The speculation that amyloid causes Alzheimer’s dominates the sphere and drives the huge bulk of pharmaceutical analysis. Yet till lecanemab, each experimental drug that succeeded in blocking amyloid manufacturing did not sluggish cognitive decline.

“This is an advanced illness. We will want a cocktail of remedies. It will not all be about amyloid reducing,” stated Cohen.

This picture offered by Biogen on June 7, 2021 reveals a vial and packaging for the drug Aduhelm. Much of the wariness amongst specialists about lecanemab stems from what occurred simply final yr with Aduhelm. (Biogen/The Associated Press)

Drugs like lecanemab “should be complimented, augmented by different brokers earlier than we truly get the therapeutic cocktail that is truly going to work for this devastating illness,” stated Dr. Donald Weaver, senior scientist on the University Health Network’s Krembil Brain Institute in Toronto.

“The mind is essentially the most advanced entity within the universe, and arguably Alzheimer’s is essentially the most advanced illness of the mind,” Weaver stated in an interview. “So the truth that now we have failed, and failed, and failed is no surprise.”

He contrasts treating Alzheimer’s illness with treating hypertension, a situation that he describes as mechanistically far easier.

“There is not one capsule for hypertension,” stated Weaver. “So why can we anticipate there’s going to be one magic bullet, one capsule that is going to be the treatment for Alzheimer’s illness? I feel that is naive.”

Drugs like lecanemab ‘should be complimented, augmented by different brokers earlier than we truly get the therapeutic cocktail that is truly going to work for this devastating illness,’ stated Dr. Donald Weaver, seen right here in October. (Craig Chivers/CBC)

The seek for an Alzheimer’s therapy in Weaver’s lab is pushed by his idea that amyloid is not only an evil toxin however capabilities as a part of the mind’s immune system.

In Weaver’s idea, amyloid triggers Alzheimer’s when its infection-fighting goal will get misdirected. “In its search and destroy mission to attempt to discover micro organism, it can’t inform micro organism from mind cells, and so it begins to inadvertently kill mind cells,” he stated.

This has Weaver aiming to develop medicine that modulate amyloid, reasonably than get rid of it, as carried out by monoclonal antibodies like lecanemab.

“I take a look at it like a thermostat and we’re turning [amyloid] down, turning it down so it isn’t fairly so hostile in the direction of mind cells,” he stated.

In addition to Weaver’s concept that Alzheimer’s is an auto-immune illness, different researchers are targeted on its hyperlinks to diabetes, or investigating a bunch of potential environmental and well being threat elements.

seventh main reason behind dying worldwide

Dr. Saskia Sivananthan, chief science officer on the Alzheimer’s Society of Canada, stated there’s little doubt that a number of remedies will likely be wanted.

“We’re not very far alongside and not so far as we needs to be given the impression of this illness,” stated Sivananthan. She attributes that lack of progress partly to the small share of analysis carried out on Alzheimer’s relative to such ailments as diabetes and most cancers.

Alzheimer’s illness is the seventh-leading reason behind dying globally, however accounts for lower than 1.5 per cent of the worldwide output of well being analysis, in accordance with the World Health Organization.

Still, others are hopeful about the new drug. Among them is Lorraine Klein, one of many 1,795 worldwide members within the human trial for lecanemab.

Lorraine Klein receives an infusion of the experimental Alzheimer’s drug lecanemab on the Toronto Memory Clinic on Nov 17. She was one of many 1,795 members in a human trial of the remedy, developed by two pharmaceutical corporations, Biogen and Eisai. (Mike Crawley/CBC)

Every two weeks beginning in 2020, Klein made the 90-minute journey from her house in Cobourg, Ont., to the Toronto Memory Clinic to obtain an intravenous infusion, not understanding if it was the drug or a placebo. 

She nonetheless does not know, however now that the analysis part of the trial is over, she is definitively on lecanemab. 

“I’m very completely satisfied about that, may do away with the amyloid protein in my mind,” Klein stated because the lecanemab IV flowed into her bloodstream.

Klein, 73, works as a grocery retailer cashier and says she discovered herself unable to recollect the quantity codes for sure greens. Cognitive assessments and a mind scan confirmed the early levels of Alzheimer’s, making her eligible for the lecanemab research.

“In the start, I used to be actually afraid,” Klein stated, including that her greatest concern is forgetting her husband. “I’ve been married 54 years. I can not think about not remembering him.” 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here